Sign In Forgot Password
בס״ד

Talmud in Verse

 

Dear Rabbi New and dear friends, 

Subsequent to writing a sonnet for each Torah Parsha of the year which I had the privilege of sharing with all of you, I now undertake a new endeavour.  

After having studied the Talmud, systematically, following the Daf Yomi cycle, late each night, just after Mariv  and before retiring, it is with joy and anticipation that I look forward to writing a sonnet for each Tractate (Mesechta), henceforth, with G-d’s help, for the next seven and a half years: on average, one every couple of months, as each Tractate is concluded, in the Daf Yomi Calendar cycle. 

Justice Michel M.J. Shore

 

 

Sonnet for Tractate Brachot

 

How could we ever laud You enough, dear L-rd!

Like a child to an umbilical chord,

We owe all to You from night to light;

And, all in between is attributed to Your Might.

 

We thank you L-rd, the Architect of all,

The Sculptor, the Gardener, the Judge and King.

We must ensure, we always hear Your call.

It is for You, L-rd, that praises we sing.

 

Given a banquet in which we eat and drink,

And, all we see, hear, say, do or think

Is owed to You, L-rd, our lives' very link;

Only, through You, L-rd, are we saved from the brink

 

What can we add in gratitude to you?

To walk in Your Holy Ways, as partners, true.⬢

 

 

Sonnet for Tractate Shabbat

 

 Every Shabbat is our honeymoon with G-d.

Would we work on a honeymoon or rather laud?

Greet the Shabbat with Leha Dodi;

Observe and Remember and truly see.

 

Each week recall G-d's dowry and present;

Love bestowed in beauty its Covenant.

Thirty-nine labours are prohibited

To awaken our renewed soul, thus gifted.

 

How could we depart from our love’s groove

Further than the area of our Eruv?

To carry a burden would not behoove

Love which remains from which not to move.

 

The Respect and Honour within our gates,

The treasure of Shabbat that love celebrates.⬢

 

 

Sonnet for Tractate Shevuot


To take an oath is a serious matter; 

A vow is of a category latter. 

Mesechet Shevuot is one of oaths; 

Nedarim speaks of vows, uttered by mouths. 

 

That which can be pronounced by our lips

requires discipline for words spoken, need grips.

Shevuot ha'edot, testimony in Court 

must  bear truth, or a witness commits a tort. 

 

Shevuot hapikadon to change one's statement

bodes grave consequences in an assortment.

Modeh b'mikzat stating to owe a fraction, 

or Kofer hakol to deny true debt needs a sanction. 

 

An employee remembers when he is paid; 

An employer, a mistake may have made.⬢

 

 

Sonnet for Tractate Avodah Zara

 

How with all one’s being to laud G-d!

Avodah Zara is a guide to direction.

What must one do to worship the one G-d

To eschew in word, thought and deed any deviation.

 

Love the Lord Our God, with all one’s heart, soul and might.

To reflect God in all action, taste, sound and sight. (1)

Aversion to idolatry, a shofar blast

Warning of temptations to pocket, anger and lust.

 

The one God, Master of the universe

Revealed himself to Abraham, Isaac and Jacob;

To Moses in the desert's stillness;

In Sinai to Israel, never God’s honor to rob!

 

The lessons of tractate Avodah Zara

 Are evermore but to cleave to the Torah!⬢

 

  1. which include avoidance of certain business transactions, in time and location, nutrition, alcohol consumption and  immoral conduct interactions with idolaters.

 

 

A Sonnet for Tractate Horayoth

 

How does a Court admit to an error made?

How do leaders rectify a mistake?

By recognizing that such does not fade

Until a public offering is made  for its sake.

 

When the Mufla Beth Din was absent,

The High Court in its entirety had not ruled.

Thus, the judgment was not as it was meant;

The absence of the lead scholar, its judgment annulled.

 

No Court atonement could serve for the deed;

As such judgment for the community should not proceed.

Authorities could not substitute a sin offering,

As the judgment was not meant to bring suffering.

 

A leader, who brings a community to err,

Must such full responsibility bear.⬢

 

 

Sonnet for Mesechta Chullin

 

To decide what is sacred? What is profane?

How can Holiness be able to gain?

The Divine scheme does sanctify all life.

To shecht meat for food means more than a knife.

 

By whom and how will the shechting be done?

Refined knowledge and intention, no dry run.

Divine creation must be kept sacred,

To recall holy sparks by those to be fed.

 

Eating meat was a concession to humans made;

(Bereishit 1:29) yet, sacredness of purpose must never fade.

What can be eaten and what is set aside?

To transcend the primitive with Halacha's  guide.

 

Animals permitted and others forbidden,

To reveal holiness that is not hidden.⬢

(Vayikra  11:44 and Devarim 14:21)



 

Sonnet for Tractate Arakhin

 

How does one determine a valuation

In one's vow of donation for G--d's grace?

The Torah specifies the evaluation

As an income tax of the soul for Temple and priests as its base..

 

How does one make an assessment

In one's worship for spiritual investment?

Just as an accountant can determine value,

The tractate gives appropriation its due.

 

One does calculate one’s own ledger’s worth;

Individuals are reckoned from a month after birth.

Valuations are deciphered for houses and fields;

Mobile property and real estate transactions are sealed.

 

Redemption of one's heritage property

And the Jubilee year must be accounted for surety.

 

 

Sonnet for Tractate Temura

 

Substitution of an animal’s kin

For restitution of a sin,

By a gift of consecration in His Name

May not be acceptable, if it is lame.

 

Recognizing the animal must be tame,

And, if blemished, it is not the same,

For purposes of sanctification in His Name

And, not for expectation of material gain.

 

The language by which one does consecrate

Through vows that must not desecrate,

With neither offerings of any ill-gotten gain,

Nor having caused demised or pain.

 

The very reason for the offerings,

Also, has as its purpose to alleviate sufferings.⬢

 

 

Sonnet for Tractate Karetot

 

Liable or not liable, not sure;

Yet, if certain of a commitment of a sin,

Then a Korban Hatat to adjure

To the truth for atonement.

 

If not certain of a sin committed,

Then an Asham Tuluy to befit it.

Wittingly or unwittingly, to limit

One's transgression and towards purity submit

 

For sins of incest and adultery,

Also, as a guilt for impurity, Hatat Kevu'ah,

Recognizing the temporary pleasures as reverie

Scarring morality with its assault and battery

 

On the purity of the soul's integrity,

Also, negating sanctification and worship by idolatry.⬢

 

 

A Sonnet for Tractate Tamid

 

The sanctity of the Temple remains,

As ushered in Psalms by the Temple priests,

Each day, a different song, its echo proclaims:

The earth is the L-rd’s, in his Harvests are Feasts.

 

Almighty is the L-rd and highly praised

In the city of Our L-rd, and His holy mountain.

In His honour, offerings and tributes are raised,

Recognizing life is from His Source's Fountain.

 

The Lord is a witness to all, thus, the judges.

Nothing is able to withstand that which He lodges

      and dislodges.

Sing and praise to our Creator, our Liberator.

Nothing and no one was, is, or could be greater.

 

Sing for the time to come; and, it will become,

A Shabbat forever, eternity in Psalm.⬢

 

 

Sonnet for Tractate Niddah

 

G-d gave the waters of purification,

With the very birth of creation,

To provide for humanity’s sanctification,

Subsequent to any impurity’s diversion,

 

The Mikvah's natural rainwater,

Flows from Gan Aiden for both son and daughter.

For life’s purpose is Sanctity from G-dliness;

Thus, to immerse and reconnect to holiness.

 

As in the Song of Songs, the beloved to protect

With patience and honor, is a sign of respect,

Of true love for one’s partner,

Recognizing the care of the Gardener.

 

In order for seeds to flower and bloom,

And, to bring back the Garden of Eden soon.⬢

 

 

Sonnet for Tractate Eruvin


Shabbat is not in time and space, normalcy.

Shabbat touches the hem of eternity;

To live without a burden to carry;

With no weight from the week to tarry.

 

Any arrangement from public to private space,

Must then set aside the week and its pace.

It is not meant for us to race.

It is for us but to rest in G-d’s grace.

 

Let us then rest with, and in, G-d’s Makom.

“And turn away our foot", Shabbat has come.

Let us ensure before Shabbat, all is done;

To welcome the bride with the setting sun.

 

Leave any and all burdens from the week;

To enter G-d’s palace with our souls, but Unity to seek.  

 

 

 

Sonnet for Tractate Pesahim


What does the Tractate Pesahim teach us?

The story, background, setting, props and stage.

For us, now, to relive the exodus;

Cross the Red Sea, imbibe, digest and gage.

 

Whether we have absorbed Freedom's Song,

Separating ego from ourselves and our throng?

By our avodah to dismiss the fusion

Of oppression and inner illusion.

 

The four mandatory cups of wine

Demonstrate the Divine Presence as a sign,

That G-d takes, rescues, redeems and brings us

To freedom which at each Seder we discuss.

 

Why the four cups of wine, three matzot, lamb,

Bitter herbs and haroset? As signs, do oppression ban.

 

 

 

Sonnet for Tractate Shekalim

 

How does one contribute to the Temple?

Not simply with donation but with heart.

The contribution of the half -shekel was ample

For each to become whole with another part.

 

The set time for the offering was key.

A pledge duly paid makes a person free.

A mitzvah fulfilled is the key

For success in life in all we see.

 

The funds  were scrupulously managed:

The chief officers in administration,

With thirteen different chests for verification,

Two for shekels, no accounting bandaged.

 

Any money, if found, on temple premises

Served as an offering for the gift of our genesis.

 

(Footnote - Explanation for last line of  the Sonnet)

In recognition that we are frail and we make mistakes,

Our offerings, at times, serve as repentance

for who we were, in order to become, who we could be.

 

 

     Sonnet for Tractate Yoma

 

The High Priest had the monumental task,

To represent Klal Israel and thus to grasp,

The solemnity in radiance without ego's mask.

As the Judge of Judges decides who shall last.

 

Entering the Sanctity of time and space,

In the Holy of Holies for Klal Israel to face;

Almighty's judgment, may it be with grace.

For the Heshbon Hanefesh, a new year to trace.

 

A road for the future from lessons of the past;

For tshuva to renew life to Mashiach, at last;

In purity, the High priest as the Klal did fast;

To cleanse all sins of which Torah is aghast.

 

To take as a nation its ethical temperature:

Is the soul's tax pledge for the future.

 

 

   Sonnet for Tractate Sukkah

 

The temporary Sukkah is a symbol

Of the transitory nature of life;

Only in G-d’s embrace can security fulfil

The Sukkah Shlema, in time and space of strife.

 

Divine law ingathers us all as one,

As the etrog, lulav, hadas and arava,

Each a distinct trait, yet, each a daughter and son.

Blessed in all, we posses, given just as manna.

 

The parameters, walls and shak of the Sukkah,

Embodiment of measures for fulfillment

Of responsibility, not as a detriment

But to embrace all-in G-d’s  Sukkah.

 

The final narrative, a paradox,

Miriam of the Bilga clan’s example talks.

 

(The hope is the to entice the reader  of the Sonnet to read or hear the story as an illustration of unity and its converse.)

 

 

   Sonnet for Tractate Beitza

 

How is Yom Tov different from Shabbat?

Exodus 12:16, its festiveness,

Explains itself in preparation selectiveness,

As to what to the table can be brought.

 

Enough food for each person, without automation,

As our past lacked refrigeration,

Carriage from one domain to another

Did not adherence to these laws bother.

 

Animals which slept in pastures or elsewhere,

And not in our locale, familiar,

Eggs hatched on holidays and not before,

Could not on Yom Tov be cooked within our doors.

 

Deep within ourselves, what does it all mean?

To celebrate but curb, yetzer hara of sin.

 

 

   Sonnet for Tractate Rosh Hashana

 

 What does it mean to mark time through space?

 Where does it begin? To what does time amount?

 Tractate Rosh Hashana teaches chronologies of G-d's grace.

 In quantity and quality, how to make time, count!

 

What are we to do with the passage of time?

 Thus, a Tractate for calculating time-line.

 It begins with Passover and freedom in Nissan.

 But, Divine creation, in Tishrei, with the moon and sun.

 

Monthly calculations are lunar based;

 With assurances that seasons are solar traced.

 The conscience, too, is called to account with blasts:

 The shofar calls, crowns, proclaims, alerts and grasps.

 

That we must not only count time but make time count.

 Thus, the kavana of prayer is accounted as paramount.

 

 

Sonnet for Tractate Ta'anit

 

When, why and how to fast on chosen days?

Examination of the conscience, thus, says:

What is it we must examine in ourselves?

Our ethical temperature then delves

 

Into that which we must fix to better serve

G-d, who constantly in our midst remains ;

And listens to our Shmone Esrei, words in reserve

For times of life's dryness, supplicating for rains.

 

The Ark is transported from the Temple

To stand as witness in the City's open space ;

Clothed in sackcloth with ashes , people tremble

As the Shofar is blown to plead for God's grace.

 

The Tractate’s end brings a message of hope,

After days of sadness, promised joy allows us to cope.

 

 

Sonnet for Tractate Megillah (Esther)

 

What’s in a story, much by which to learn

What it means to be in narrow exile!

Tractate Megillah teaches as the world does turn;

Never to forget Amalek and his guile.

 

The story in its hidden layers brings a sigh,

Inflicted on many voiceless due to a lie.

Antisemitism has so many guises,

Without denouncement of all hatred’s vices.

 

How to honour public readings of Torah;

And the Commandment to read the Megillah

Are gifts of knowledge bestowed by the Tractate;

Walled cities from time of Joshua give the date,

 

When to commemorate and then celebrate,

G-d’s hidden work that saves our fate.

 

 

Sonnet for Tractate Moed Katan

 

For everything there is a season;

There is a time and place with reason.

There is a time to celebrate;

And a time to commemorate.

 

There is a time to heal from illness;

And a time to mourn in inner stillness.

A time to ameliorate,

To separate from grave Halachic mistakes made.

 

When to externally, wholly celebrate?

When to internally, in measure, celebrate?

What must be taken care of on the Moed?

And what must be left, less important, to fade?

 

For everything there is a season;

There is a time and place with reason.

 

Sonnet for Tractate Chagiga

 

Three times a year for the joyous festivals

 Pesach, Shavuot and Sukkot,

 Pilgrims streamed to enter Jerusalem's walls

 With offerings for the Temple in worship, sought.

 

Burnt offerings and festival peace offerings,

 Symbols of tshuva and gifts from the soul ,

 Both to give life meaning and transcend sufferings.                              

 Thus, celebrate life's cycle by G-d's given role.

 

 Ritual impurity and purity

 In the Temple for each ritual object's lot,

 Obliges devout care and sincerity,

 Knowing what is sacred and what is not!

 

The Divine chariot and creation

 Imprint but hide mystical formulation.

 

 

Sonnet for Tractate Yevamot

 

Not to have progeny is a tragedy;

Yevamot attempts to avoid calamity;

An unmarried brother’s responsibility,

To take as his wife, his brother’s widow in matrimony.

 

To ensure the widow’s dignity,

All is done to ensure compatibility.

Dependant on the sibling's adaptability.

For matrimonial felicity.

 

For lineage to continue in purity,

Time and rules for accountabilty,

Assess physical well-being necessity;

And psychological feasibility.

 

Decisions in an atmosphere of liberty

Require heshbon hanefesh accountability.

 

 

Sonnet for Tractate Ketuvot

 

The ramifications of a marriage

Are at the core of Talmudic discourse,

Designated as a “miniature Talmud”1

Or a “master key to the Talmud itself.”2

 

Respect, honor, dignity, well being

Establish the climate of confidence,

As sacred watchwords for the relationship’s

Intimacy, security and well being.3

 

Thus, sustenance, appearance, nourishment,

Living quarters are the husband's responsibility.

The mutual obligations of both spouses

Mark a sanctified bond for reverence.

 

Divorce or death of the husband unfolds

A regime of guarantees for the wife's needs.

1 Shas Katan
2 Mafte’ah ha’Shas
3 physical and psychological health

 

Sonnet for Tractate Nedarim

 

Dedicated to the memory of Shimshon ben ha’Rav Michael Arié, Sigmond Shore, my Father O.B.M., who taught me at the age of four, by shaking my hand in his, that my word is my bond- a sacred promise.

 

Never make a promise, you cannot keep;

A word is a bond, once uttered, captive

To its formulation, in time and space;

Thus, every word must be filterd, thought out.

 

“Moses spoke to the leaders of the tribes;

If a man takes, upon himself, a vow…

He shall not desecrate, his uttered word;

That which he transmits, he must then fulfill.”*

 

A promise, inadvertently given,

Or based on lack of knowledge, intention,

Can be disavowed, if demonstrated

To lack understanding  of consequences.

 

Protection of a husband or Father,

Or authority, caught in time, disavows.

(*Numbers 30:2-3)

 

Sonnet for Tractate Nazir

 

Is there not enough to uphold? What more?

If one who denies himself wine is a sinner,

How much more so, an ascetic in all!

Why deny what God permitted and gave?  (Numbers 6 : 1 to 21)

 

In the three pronouncements uttered in vows :

Straight forward, the Samson and lifelong vows : 

What are the obligations in length and breadth?

And, what responsibilities, thus, entail?

 

The shaving of hair upon completion,

And ritual cleansing on termination,

Then narratives recount of dire dangers

 Removed by vows which rescued from hostile strangers.

 

When and by whom, then, could vows be annuled?

When are they fulfilled, for life to begin anew?

 

 

Sonnet for Tractate Sotah

In honor of Rabbi Levi New of the Montreal Torah Center: Rabbi Levi New taught more than four hundred sessions to impart the intricacies of this Tractate. The sessions are fortunately available on YouTube here.


The sacredness of marriage Is sublime;

Based on the sanctity of precious time.

For each moment is brought into account;

Recognizing, there is no room for doubt.

 

G-d did give us the treasure of pure souls;

How do we truly live with righteous goals?

A test had been devised, in time, set aside;

The tractate teaches for nothing to hide.

 

The first century’s era brought to life,

Roman legions who then did sow strife.

The era concludes, history meeting

KIng Agrippa’s public Torah reading.

 

And, the attributes of Talmudic sages

Are then demonstrated on the last pages.⬢

 

Sonnet for Tractate Kiddushim
 

Kiddushin- betrothal is commitment,

Acknowledgement of a permanent union.

Its responsibility is fulfillment

Through gift, document, intimate union.

 

The covenant is attested by two witnesses;

As the pact between G-d and Israel,

Is a sacred bond, bound by promise,

As is witnessed by both heaven and earth.

 

The Chuppah, a physical manifestation,

Of the home to nurture a family,

Is incorporated into the Nissuin.

 Not forgotten are slaves or animals.

 

Commitment does not have a recess, or pause.

All acts in a home reflect that commitment.

              To cosmic ethical harmony.⬢

 

Sonnet for Tractate Kiddushim


The civil law teachings of Baba Kama

Open the judicial portals of reason,

To intricately solve all cases

Of damages to property and persons.

 

Damages perpetrated are resolved

By levels of responsibility.

Damages committed by accident

Are different then those by intention.

 

An assessment is value calculated

By degree of injury and suffering,

By assessment of needs for recovery

With full account taken for lost wages.

 

Even embarrassment takes its toll,

Both emotional and physical, thus, all.⬢

 

( Bava Kama interprets Parsha Mishpatim, in Exodus, 21:18-37 and 22:1-14)

 

Sonnet for Tractate Bava Metzia

An ancient people in an ancient land

Received a barometer of morality;

And a thermometer of ethics at G-d’s command

Of Halakhot explained with practicality.

 

Rightful ownership through acquisition

Needs safeguards from misappropriation.

Owners of property give different mandates

For custodians to respect, or the owner litigates.

 

Exploitation of another is disrespect of your brother.

G-d gives all and usury hurts another.

How are risks and dangers assessed?

For craftsman, harvesters and lessees to feel blessed.

 

The letter of the law is to be applied;

But the spirit of the law must not be denied.⬢

 

Sonnet for Tractate Bava Batra
​​​​​​​

The scale of values in each transaction

In Bava Batra exemplifies dignity,

Given to each person in property

Exchanges and transfers of sales and wills.

 

The degree of adherence of respect,

Dependent on proper title, results

In weighing the evidence variables

In bills of sale, deeds of gifts and testaments.

 

From land and crop transfers to ship purchases;

To ensuring precise weights and measures

And designating public and private property

Also, with support for unmarried daughters.

 

Therefore, the need for clarity in deeds

Bodes respect for the will of signatories.⬢

Tue, January 7 2025 7 Tevet 5785